Freedom vs. Easy Walk vs. Balance: Which No-Pull Harness Actually Stops Pulling?

Affiliate disclosure: this article contains affiliate links. forhappydogs.com may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

The Dog Owner's Planner
From the For Happy Dogs shop
Keep every record in one place

Vaccines, medications, vet visits, weight, feeding, a symptom diary and pet-sitter sheets, in one 44-page fillable planner you can type into or print.

Get The Dog Owner’s Planner ยท $9.99 on Etsy โ†’

The short answer

These three harnesses get recommended constantly, and they are not interchangeable. They stop pulling in genuinely different ways.

PetSafe Easy Walk2 Hounds Freedom
also on Amazon
Blue-9 Balance
Price~$23~$46 (incl. leash)~$50
Leash attachmentFront onlyFront and backFront and back
How it worksMartingale loop across the chest tightens when the dog pullsMartingale loop on the back cinches the chest strapNo tightening โ€” control comes from fit and the dual-clip leash
Adjustment points446
Front strap positionStraight across the shouldersStraight across the shouldersY-front, sits clear of the shoulder joint
Chafe protectionNoneVelvet-lined girth strapWide, flat webbing
Best forTight budgets, short-term trainingAll-rounder, most dogsOdd body shapes, active/long-term wear

If you want one sentence: buy the Easy Walk if budget is the deciding factor, the Freedom (direct, or on Amazon) if you want the best all-round no-pull harness, and the Balance if your dog is hard to fit or wears a harness for hours at a time.

Why the mechanism matters more than the brand

Every “no-pull” harness works by making pulling less rewarding. The three designs here do it in three different ways, and that difference is the whole decision.

Pressure-based (Easy Walk). A martingale loop sits on the chest strap. When your dog pulls, the loop tightens and the strap pulls across the front of the shoulders, turning the dog gently back toward you. It’s effective and it’s cheap. The trade-off is that the strap crosses directly over the shoulder joint, which is why trainers who work with sport and working dogs tend to steer away from it for all-day wear.

Redirection-based (Freedom). The martingale loop sits on the back instead. When your dog pulls, the loop cinches the chest strap slightly under the front legs rather than across the shoulders. Paired with the included double-ended leash โ€” one clip front, one clip back โ€” you get a steering effect rather than a bracing effect. This is the design most people mean when they say a harness “works without choking.”

Fit-based (Balance). Blue-9 doesn’t tighten anything. It has six adjustment points and a Y-shaped front that sits below the throat and clear of the shoulder, so the dog’s gait isn’t restricted. Control comes from a snug custom fit plus a front clip. It asks more of you as a handler โ€” it isn’t a device that corrects pulling on its own โ€” but it’s the most comfortable of the three for a dog who lives in a harness.

PetSafe Easy Walk โ€” best on a budget

Price: ~$22.98 ยท Clips: front only ยท ASIN: B007S9JOO4

The Easy Walk is the most-sold no-pull harness in the world, and for a dog who pulls moderately it does the job on day one. Four adjustment points, a simple buckle, and a price that makes it easy to try.

What’s good

  • Cheapest way to find out whether a front-clip harness helps your dog at all.
  • Genuinely simple to fit โ€” two straps, four sliders.
  • The martingale chest loop gives immediate feedback, so many dogs slow down within a walk or two.

What’s not

  • The strap crosses the shoulders. For a dog who wears it for an hour a day, this is a non-issue. For a hiking or running dog, it restricts the shoulder’s range of motion.
  • Front clip only. No back attachment, so you can’t switch to a relaxed back-clip walk once training sticks.
  • It can slide sideways. The chest strap has a habit of rotating out of position on deep-chested dogs, which kills the effect until you straighten it.
  • Nylon webbing directly against the armpit โ€” the most common chafe complaint of the three.

Buy it if you want to test the concept cheaply, your dog pulls moderately, and walks are 30โ€“60 minutes on flat ground.

Check the current price on Amazon โ†’

2 Hounds Design Freedom โ€” best overall

Price: ~$45.96 (harness and double-connection leash) ยท Clips: front and back

This is the one that shows up in most “what actually worked” threads, and the reason is the back-mounted martingale combined with the included two-ended leash.

What’s good

  • Dual attachment. Clip the front for control, the back for casual walks, or both ends of the included leash for genuine two-point steering. That last configuration is what makes the difference on a strong puller.
  • Velvet-lined girth strap. The strap that sits behind the front legs โ€” the one that chafes on most harnesses โ€” is lined. This is a small thing that matters a lot on a short-coated dog.
  • The leash is included. At ~$46 you’re getting a harness plus a $25-ish double-ended training leash, which makes the real price gap against the Easy Walk much smaller than it looks.
  • Made in the USA, and 2 Hounds will replace chewed straps rather than making you rebuy.

What’s not

  • Four adjustment points, not six โ€” a barrel-chested or very narrow dog can still end up between sizes.
  • The front strap still runs across the shoulders, though the back-martingale geometry reduces how hard it presses there.
  • You have to actually use the double-ended leash to get the full benefit. Clipped front-only, it behaves like a nicer Easy Walk.

Buy it if you want the single best-value no-pull setup and your dog is a normal-ish shape. This is the default recommendation for most dogs.

Check the current price at 2 Hounds Design โ†’ ยท or on Amazon โ†’

Blue-9 Balance โ€” best fit and best for all-day wear

Price: ~$49.95 ยท Clips: front and back ยท ASIN: B07B9RQMBL

The Balance is the harness trainers buy for their own dogs. It’s the only one of the three built around fit rather than correction.

What’s good

  • Six adjustment points. Neck, chest, girth, and the strap lengths between them. If your dog is between sizes on everything else โ€” greyhounds, bulldogs, deep-chested mixes โ€” this is the one that will actually fit.
  • Y-front. The chest strap forms a Y that sits below the throat and outside the shoulder joint. Full range of motion, which is why it’s the pick for hiking, running, and dogs who wear a harness most of the day.
  • No tightening mechanism means nothing digs in on a long wear.
  • Buckle-neck version goes on without lifting it over the head โ€” a real advantage for head-shy or arthritic dogs.

What’s not

  • It will not stop pulling by itself. There’s no martingale, no pressure point. It gives you a front clip and a good fit; the rest is training. If you want equipment that does the work, this isn’t it.
  • Most expensive, and no leash included.
  • Six adjustment points means the first fitting takes 10โ€“15 minutes and a tape measure. Get it wrong and you lose the main advantage.

Buy it if your dog is hard to fit, is athletic, wears the harness for hours, or you’re already doing structured loose-leash training.

Check the current price on Amazon โ†’

Head to head: the questions people actually ask

Freedom vs. Easy Walk โ€” which is better?

The Freedom, for most dogs, and the gap is bigger than the price difference suggests. You get a second attachment point, the double-ended leash in the box, and a lined girth strap. The Easy Walk’s advantage is purely cost. If $23 versus $46 is the deciding factor, the Easy Walk is a legitimate choice and will help โ€” just expect more strap-rotation fiddling and no back-clip option later.

Balance vs. Freedom โ€” which is better?

Different jobs. The Freedom is a no-pull tool: it applies gentle pressure that discourages pulling. The Balance is a well-fitting harness: it gives you control and comfort but leaves the pulling problem to training.

Pick the Freedom if your dog currently drags you down the street and you want help this week. Pick the Balance if your dog is reasonably trained, hard to fit, or spends hours in the harness.

Do any of these hurt the dog?

None of the three tightens around the neck or throat โ€” that’s the meaningful safety line, and all three stay on the right side of it. The relevant concern is shoulder mechanics on long-term wear: the Easy Walk restricts most, the Freedom somewhat, the Balance not at all by design. For an hour’s walk a day, any of them is fine.

Which one for a dog who slips out of harnesses?

The Balance, fitted properly with all six points โ€” an escape is nearly always a fit problem, not a design one. The Freedom is a close second thanks to the back-martingale. Learning to read the body language that comes before a bolt helps as much as the hardware โ€” see our dog body language guide.

Will a no-pull harness train my dog not to pull?

No. It manages the behaviour while it’s on. Every one of these works dramatically better alongside actual loose-leash training โ€” our walk-by-walk method is in how to stop leash pulling without a prong collar. A harness alone tends to plateau after a few weeks.

How to size any of them correctly

Two measurements, taken with a soft tape:

  1. Girth โ€” around the deepest part of the chest, just behind the front legs. This is the number that determines your size on all three.
  2. Neck/chest width โ€” for the Balance especially, measure the base of the neck where a collar would naturally sit.

Then: two fingers should slide flat under any strap. More than that and the harness will rotate; less and it will chafe. Re-check the fit after the first week โ€” webbing settles, and nearly every “it stopped working” complaint traces back to a strap that loosened.

If your dog is between sizes, size up on the Easy Walk and Freedom (the martingale takes up the slack) and measure again for the Balance (its adjustment range handles it).

Bottom line

If you’re still deciding whether a front-clip harness is the right category at all, or you want to see how these three stack up against four other options, read our full guide to the best no-pull dog harnesses.

Prices checked 2026-10-27 for the Easy Walk and Freedom (the Blue-9 price was last confirmed 2026-08-29) and will drift โ€” the links above always show Amazon’s current price.

Similar Posts